Mcgonagall then sent a orange streak of light at snape, as snape sent a blue streak. This skill likewise may be helping him deflect the magic mcgonagall is throwing at him, though it is equally possible that mcgonagall, knowing his ability, is using occlumency, as much as she is able to, to block snapes probes. Plus, snape, in the end, was acting to protect hogwarts students, not just lilys son and dumbledore was long dead then. Minerva mcgonagall in harry potter and the halfblood prince. Mar 30, 20 harry vs snape bellatrix vs mad eye snape vs james sirius vs barty crouch jr remus vs lucius kingsley vs dolohov cedric vs pettigrew draco vs ron tonks vs yaxley snape vs. Minerva mcgonagallseverus snape works archive of our own. Mcgonagall brandished her wand at a torch on the wall and it flew out of its bracket. We dont really see a proper duel between the two, because snape was likely pulling punches and not trying to really injure mcgonagall.
Mcgonagall replaces dumbledore after his death in harry potter and the halfblood prince. Snape breaks and runs when flitwick and sprout, followed by slughorn, approach, and snape crashes through a window, soaring away. Who was the headmaster of hogwarts after mcgonagall got to. Harry witnessed professor mcgonagall walking right past peeves who was determinedly loosening a crystal chandelier and could have sworn he heard her tell the poltergeist out of the corner of her mouth, it unscrews the other way. The power of a mothers love saved harry from dying the night his parents did. And remember, if you buy it at target, you will also get the documentary when harry left hogwarts. At the same time, we know it is in transfiguration that min. Professor mcgonagall is the rather strict, stern, but, nonetheless caring head of gryffindor house and transfiguration teacher. Whether she can win or not is another question but she can hold her own and then she had aid from two of the most powerful witches and wizards of the age mcgonagall and snape. They both become headmaster and headmistress someday, and mcgonagall is older than snape seeing as when snape was in school mcgonagall was still deputy headmistress, but snape too, is very skilled and learned from lord voldemort.
Apr 18, 2016 of the realistic and amazingly developed characters in harry potter, professor mcgonagall is by far one of my favorites. In there you will find mcgonagall out matching snape true he fled to the other heads of houses arrival but jk rowling herself has said on a fan answer page that had the duel continued mcgonagall would have won even if by a short stretch. Rowling fought for mcgonagalls battle the mary sue. Jam city, the developers behind the upcoming mobile game harry potter. Severus snape and minerva mcgonagall have a long standing tradition that cannot be stopped. It was the next day and im going to the headmaster to see him because with being on the board of governers i get to come around. Hello, professor mcgonagall, said moody calmly, bouncing. He was fighting for dear life and when sprout, slughorn and flitwick came, he had to flee.
Her hair had come undone from the battle and she had a gash on her cheek. Who would win in a duel minerva mcgonagall or alecto. Shes stern, loyal, encouraging, yet unwavering, and my only sadness is. The following fictional characters are staff members and denizens of hogwarts in the harry potter books written. William mcgonagalls parents, charles and margaret, were irish. The sacking of severus snape wikibooks, open books for. Rowling brought us the world of harry potter and endowed it with an impressive number of secrets. The pair, with flitwicks help, go about protecting the castle from voldemort, and despite flitwicks protests, sprout supports mcgonagalls decision to protect the castle, and the two friends share a look of grim. Some she only revealed after the last book had been written, some are found by fans, and some arent hidden at all. William mcgonagall s parents, charles and margaret, were irish.
Snape enters the fray, asks mcgonagall if shes helping potter, and they end. James vs snape barty crouch jr vs neville harry vs bellatrix ron vs draco lucius vs sirius cedric vs pettigrew tonks vs dolohov mcgonagall vs carows rookwood vs kingsley lupin vs yaxley fleur v hermione cho vs ginny snape vs. Harry, about to curse snape, was forced to pull luna out of the way of the descending flames, which became a ring of fire that filled the corridor and flew like a lasso at snape then it was no longer fire, but a great, black serpent that mcgonagall blasted. Of the realistic and amazingly developed characters in harry potter, professor mcgonagall is by far one of my favorites. We have what mcgonagall says which is that peter hero worshipped james, nothing. Throughout the series, particularly in the books, professor mcgonagall disses umbridge with. Since then, thousands of people the world over have enjoyed the verse of scotlands alternative national poet. William topaz mcgonagall was a selfeducated hand loom weaver who, in dundee in 1877, felt the poetic muse upon him.
My favorite character is professor mcgonagall, which ive learned is not a popular opinion. Professor mcgonagall is an incredibly powerful witch, but so is severus snape. Miriam margolyes as pomona sprout, gemma jones as poppy pomfrey, jim broadbent as horace slughorn, and david bradley as argus filch. Mcgonagall is shown to have a strong offense in fact it nearly overwhelmed snape in the book. Part 2 instead of mcgonagall, who fought snape in the book. Who would win a duel between severus snape and minerva. Snape likely perceived harrys presence under the invisibility cloak. Im walking down the corridors in my professional robes and all the stude. She protects harry, just like his mother did when he was a baby, and fights snape. He was personally killed by lord voldemort and his snake, nagini. There is no proof in the books that snape used the word mudblood other than this. It would be a close duel, but mcgonagall would emerge victorious. Apr 04, 2010 who s better at duel between these two harry potter characters.
Hogwarts mystery may not be the nianticdeveloped augmented reality game due out in the second half of 2018, but it has created quite a bit of buzz for itself nevertheless. Pick your favorite, then tell us why in the comments below. Apr 29, 2014 headmaster severus snape vs professor mcgonagall in hd. The ousting of severus snape also improperly referred to as the sacking of severus snape was a duel between severus snape, then headmaster of hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry, and the hogwarts heads of houses. At the age of twentyone, severus snape is about to become one of the youngest professors ever taken on at hogwarts, a position he takes with some reluctance. This video is a scene from the last harry potter movie, where harry potter confronts snape about dumbledores death in front of everyone, and when snape takes out his wand to potentially fight harry, mcgonagall steps in front of harry. Later, as a mill worker, he used to read books in the evening, taking great interest in shakespeares plays. Headmaster severus snape vs professor mcgonagall in hd. All in all, snape is highly talented with dark magic, mcgonagall doesnt have any significant specialty in defense against the dark arts. Severus snape was potions master, defense against the dark arts teacher, and head of slytherin at hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry. This skill likewise may be helping him deflect the magic mcgonagall is throwing at him, though it is equally possible that mcgonagall, knowing his ability, is using occlumency, as much as she is able to, to block snape s probes.
Severus, whose father was neglectful and possibly even violent, began to identify with his mothers family and created a secret nickname from his mothers maiden name, calling himself the halfblood prince. Dec 12, 2016 following mcgonagalls duel with snape in the deathly hallows, sprout comes to her aid, forcing snape to flee. Who would win in a duel minerva mcgonagall or alecto carrow. In 1877, mcgonagall suddenly discovered himself to be a poet. He spent the next twentyfive years appalling and delighting audiences with his disjointed, creaky and sometimes just plain bad verse. Mcgonagall is gifted in transfiguration, and snape in potions, neither of which are really useful in duel, though from those 2 id say transfiguration has the edge, but snape is also well versed in dark arts, something we dont about mcgonagall, so id say that gives snape the edge. Having defeated alecto and amycus carrow on the ravenclaw tower, harry potter and luna lovegood both under the invisibility cloak along with minerva mcgonagall went. Muggles guide to harry pottercharactersminerva mcgonagall. Nobody moved as the two teachers observed the scene. Order of the phoenix professor mcgonagall is the rather strict, stern, but, nonetheless caring head of gryffindor house and transfiguration teacher. Harry, about to curse snape, was forced to pull luna out of the way of the descending flames, which became a ring of fire that filled the corridor and flew like a lasso at snape then it was no longer fire, but a great black serpent that mcgonagall blasted to smoke, which reformed and solidified in seconds to become a swarm of pursuing daggers. Part 2 will be released on dvd and bluray on november 11.
When it comes to harry potter, all fans are quite passionate about defending their favorite character. Hes also way younger so thats got to count for him as well. In harry potter and the chamber of secrets, professor mcgonagall replaces professor dumbledore after his resignation is forced by lucius malfoy. Mcgonagall vs snape, a harry potter fanfic fanfiction. So today its just me due to stacey is teaching dada and joanne is doing charms. The series focuses much more on severus snape s magical prowess and his mastery of occlumency which is amazing, but very little information is av. For example, despite the fact that the movies are iconic to so many people, some characters dont exactly match their descriptions from the books. Even though alecto carrow has learnt many dark skills from voldemort, she isnt that clever, and minerva mcgonagall is wiser, cleverer, and knows more spells than. Click here to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links. Hogwarts mystery, announce its release date and reveal that it will. Mcgonagall woukd win hands down and you know she would if you have ever had the courtesy to read the book. She protects harry, just like his mother did when he was a. Severus snape suddenly appears, demanding to know what is happening.
Its time to find out once and for all who is the best harry potter character. Harry vs snape bellatrix vs mad eye snape vs james sirius vs barty crouch jr remus vs lucius kingsley vs dolohov cedric vs pettigrew draco vs ron tonks vs yaxley snape vs. Snape s suspicions of mcgonagall s explanation escalates into a fierce duel. Whos better at duel between these two harry potter characters. Mcgonagall orders the castle to prepare for battle. His double life played an extremely important role in both of the wizarding. So the fact that snape is younger and physically stronger is not a factor that should be considered nor used. Who was the headmaster of hogwarts after mcgonagall. If they met in combat with no outside influence, who would come out on top. See more ideas about harry potter, hogwarts and maggie smith. Throughout his adult life he claimed to have been born in edinburgh, giving his year of birth variously as 1825 or 1830, but his entry in the 1841 census gives his place of birth, like his parents, as ireland.
Severus snape is appointed headmaster the following year. As is confirmed in the tales of beedle the bard, mcgonagall becomes headmistress of hogwarts after the battle of hogwarts and snape s death. Rowling fought for mcgonagall s battle the mary sue. Snape had seen the gryffindor group first and knew that alex was involved and he hoped it was out of retaliation. But as far as feats go, i think both books and movies show snape with far more combat power, prowess, and superior tutelage essentially learning from the two most powerful wizards, dumbledore and voldemort. Severus snape was born 9 january, 1960 to eileen prince, a pureblood witch, and tobias snape, a muggle, making him a halfblood wizard. The sacking of severus snape wikibooks, open books for an. Four hogwarts staff members in harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2. See more ideas about harry potter, harry potter love and harry potter universal. Voldemort, snape, malfoy, petigrew, and karkaroff harry vs. Rowling, on fighting the decision to pit harry potter against severus snape in harry potter and the deathly hallows.
Though other professors come and go the two heads of house routinely meet by the staff room fireside on friday nights to cope with the struggles of teaching at a magical school filled with teenagers. His irish surname is a variation on mag congail, a popular name in county donegal. They both become headmaster and headmistress someday, and mcgonagall is older than snapeseeing as when snape was in school mcgonagall was still deputy headmistress, but snape too, is very skilled and learned from lord voldemort. In harry potter, who was headmaster after mcgonagall. When it comes to any beloved series, all fans have their favorite character.
Having defeated alecto and amycus carrow on the ravenclaw tower, harry potter and luna lovegood both under the invisibility cloak along with minerva mcgonagall went down. Mcgonogall looked over all of the students and gasped when she saw ginny and the other gryffindors helping her stand up and she rushed over to them suporting ginny as she slowly hobbled to the rest of the group. When the wizarding war ends with the death of the potters, he must somehow manage to teach moronic teenagers all day while dealing with his grief. Mcgonagall says as she rounded a corner and spotted snape in front of the gargoyle that guards the entrance to the headmasters office. When snape is stood in front of the school during the first signs of rebellion against their death eater teachers, he chooses to run away from mcgonagall, rather than attempt to fight.
1452 829 503 59 377 595 719 155 1536 585 1026 211 806 373 836 751 263 33 263 12 1009 1184 934 1332 1075 490 113 1025 602 1395 600 488 985 1137 6 1048 571 593 885 211 443 1493